An unusual controversy is shaking the music world after an AI-generated band modeled on the Welsh rock group Holding Absence overtook them in monthly listeners on Spotify. The rapid rise of the virtual band has left Holding Absence’s frontman, Lucas Woodland, calling the situation both shocking and insulting, highlighting the uneasy crossroads of art and technology.
The AI band, believed to be Bleeding Verse, has openly cited Holding Absence as an influence yet managed to gain more traction in just two months than the real musicians who inspired it. Reports suggest that their catalog was produced in mere minutes using AI tools such as Suno, a reality that further underlines the potential disruption facing artists.
For musicians who spend years developing their craft, the sudden popularity of algorithmically produced imitators raises troubling questions. Woodland warned that if trends continue, genuine bands might “stop existing” altogether, as they are crowded out by content generated faster and at higher volumes than any human could achieve. The fear is that creativity could be overshadowed by automation.
Spotify has already removed some AI-related material deemed spam or impersonation, but the line remains blurred between acceptable AI-assisted music and outright mimicry. This case stands as a wake-up call for the industry, forcing both platforms and listeners to consider what value they place on originality, authenticity, and the irreplaceable human touch in music.
#AI #Music #Spotify #ArtificialIntelligence #Musicians #Streaming